David by Mary Hoffman
Michelangelo’s statue of David is renowned all over the world. Thousands flock to Florence to admire the artistry behind this Renaissance masterpiece, and to admire the beauty of the human form captured in the marble. But the identity of the model for this statue that has been so revered for over five hundred years has been lost .
Source - http://www.bloomsbury.com/David/Mary-Hoffman/books/details/9781408800522
It took me about 3 hours to finish this 250 page book and though I admit it is a page turner, I was quite disappointed. Mary Hoffman is not a bad writer and she’s got quite an imagination. Based on imagination alone and just some historical references, she managed to narrate the story of the mysterious model behind Michaelangelo’s David.
I am a fan of historical fiction. I’ve read books about the Borgias, countless books about the Tudors or members of the Tudor court, stories of Da Vinci and the identity behind Mona Lisa, Nefertari, Nefertiti, etc. When I picked out David during the Borders sale, I was quite excited. I haven’t read a book in the HF genre in quite a while and this seemed interesting. I love reading stories set in the renaissance. I am not usually one for putting books into age appropriate ratings but for the sake of this review, let’s just say I’m more used to reading books that were written for an older readership. Books in this category would usually be more in depth with a little more suspense to build up to the climax of this story. Mary Hoffman categorized David into Teen and Historical Fiction and the content itself does show exactly that it belongs in that category.
The book itself had a very creative and well thought out storyline but as I was reading, I couldn’t help but feel that all Mary has done is scratch the surface of the matter. I wouldn’t say that she only brings half-baked forms of what she offered but that she could delve further into the content; a little more history, more suspense, more emotions. The characters could be developed a little more for one. For example, Gabriele is this young, had working and good looking young man who got lucky with the artists and had “skirts” on his mind. He got dragged into politics and chose sides because the republicans were the first group to say hi to him and Michaelangelo was a republican. That’s it. I’m sure there’s more to him than just all that.
Throughout the book, I see references and implications of other historical figures and her take one some things that they’ve done. For example, she mentions that the painting of Mona Lisa (that Leonardo was still working on) looked exactly like the subject he was painting but it also held the face of one of Leonardo’s young assistants, implying a relation of some sort between the two. This was only mentioned in about half a page but it did enough to rouse the curiosity of readers. She didn’t go back into that or explore that option further. Is she going to write another book that explores this option? She’d be competing with many other books that have done the same and at least two books that were very well written.
But when it comes to other things like description and language, that’s perfect. I’m sure some other readers who aren’t really into the in depth books would enjoy it but for more the bookworms like me, this book wouldn’t be too satisfying.
♥























































